logoalt Hacker News

dauertewigkeit • today at 11:17 AM • 4 replies • view on HN

What's wrong with a cruise missle being defined as a robot? It is one.

Also I'd argue that a CNC machine is a robot as well, no different than a programmable industrial robotic arm.

IMHO, a dishwasher isn't a robot because it is neither versatile in its objective, nor programmable.


Replies

michaelt • today at 12:44 PM

> Also I'd argue that a CNC machine is a robot as well, no different than a programmable industrial robotic arm.

It's true - a robot arm is not so different from a CNC machine.

But a 5-axis CNC is not so different from a 3-axis CNC, a 3-axis CNC is not so different from a laser cutter, a laser cutter is not so different from a vinyl cutter, a vinyl cutter is not so different from a large-format printer, and a large-format printer is no so different from an inkjet printer.

➕ show 1 reply
PowerElectronix • today at 12:45 PM

A cruise missile is much less versatile and programmable than a dishwasher.

You can program a diswhasher to brew beer.

➕ show 1 reply
blitzar • today at 12:47 PM

> CNC machine is a robot

Who ever controls the CNC machines will win The War Against the Machines.

chii • today at 11:31 AM

> neither versatile in its objective, nor programmable.

how programmable does it have to be for the robotic classification to stick? A cruise missile also cannot be programmed to be general - you can only program it to follow a trajectory. Just like you can only program a dishwasher to do dishes in a particular way.

➕ show 2 replies