logoalt Hacker News

PessimalDecimal • yesterday at 1:34 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

Early European Farmers displaced the mesolithic Hunter Gatherers in the areas they both inhabited but there wasn't a complete elimination of the HG groups. In fact, the I1 Y haplogroup associated with Germanic tribes comes from the mesolithic Hunter Gatherers, so they obviously were _not_ totally eliminated. Actually, it was the EEF group that was more or less fully eliminated in Scandinavia when the Yamnaya appeared because both groups exploited similar areas. They wanted loess soils along rivers, while the Hunter Gatherers lived near the coastline.


Replies

cobbzilla • yesterday at 10:40 PM

> there wasn't a complete elimination of the HG groups

The annihilated culture was not worried about its haplogroups, it was worried about is survival; its dead now; its haplogroups survive so everything is fine, yes?

➕ show 1 reply
senderista • yesterday at 7:13 PM

However, the Corded Ware culture that largely displaced EEF in Europe itself had a large EEF component in addition to Yamnaya (and in some places like Sardinia EEF still dominates).

➕ show 1 reply
rightbyte • yesterday at 2:58 PM

The article is very much making up conclusions not present in the work cited. There were no "wipe outs" or "total turnovers".

Probably some sort of jingoist advocating ethnic cleansing writing articles like this.

➕ show 3 replies