logoalt Hacker News

verdverm • today at 5:03 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

> a quick fyi: in a total war everything is a valid military target

this is not true, war crimes exist and have legal definitions, even in WW2 people pushed back on some things their government decided to do, like firebombing large civilian centers

hospitals and water facilities are easy examples, which Israel is very guilty of violating in recent years


Replies

rembal • today at 5:55 PM

I would just like to point out that the court that prosecutes war crimes was just hit with even more sanctions from the US, with the justification that "nobody will hurt American citizens", buy the guy who indirectly ordered the bombing of the school. Legal definitions are pretty worthless if nobody gets prosecutesd.

smuhakg • today at 5:20 PM

> this is not true, war crimes exist and have legal definitions

That is why total wars are distinguished from a normal war. The concept that "all civilian infrastructure supports the war effort" is used in a total war to justify firebombing civilians.

thedrexster • today at 5:15 PM

> pushed back on some things their government decided to do, like firebombing large civilian centers

unless we're talking about, say, japan, where the firebombing campaigns killed more civilians than the two atomic bombs :P

➕ show 1 reply