logoalt Hacker News

233mhz • today at 1:09 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> "some people have it worse"

It's not "some people", it's the bottom 80%. You're an anomaly, the anomaly is going away, it sucks (for you) but that's what it is.

Techies have been automating people out of their jobs for decades and we're supposed to feel sorry for them now that it's their turn, cry me a river...

You might finally understand that these problems aren't technical but political, in the meantime get in line and suck it up


Replies

hackyhacky • today at 1:25 PM

*TECHNOLOGY* has been automating people out of their jobs for *CENTURIES*.

They "techies" didn't do this. Spare me your self-hating performative guilt trip.

Technology advances (beasts of burden replacing human labor, windmills replacing human labor, firearms replacing melee weapons, automatic looms replacing manual textile workers, electric light replacing manual illumination), and at each step, society as a whole benefits, but some benefit more than others: in particular the capital-owning class reap the immediate benefits, to the detriment of the labor class whose skill is devalued and whose livelihood is ruined.

This isn't new. Blaming "techies" is wrong. Point your finger at the owners who are enriching themselves at the expense of the many. In a just society, the benefits of technological advance should be shared (more) equally. A functioning democratic government would protect those whose livelihoods are at risk, because the instability of mass unemployment is more damaging to society than possibly demotivating a handful of billionaires.

➕ show 1 reply