logoalt Hacker News

righthand • yesterday at 9:59 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

> If you're a conductor, you can view the various members of your orchestra as "tools" to produce the ideal musical output.

I disagree, humans are the operators, tools are tools. Operators use tools. A conductor is an operator that uses a baton tool to direct other operators to produce the proper sound with their musical instrument tools.

I think calling people tools is dehumanizing if anything. The only way I know people can be a tool, is through an already existing insult.


Replies

thaumasiotes • today at 12:41 AM

> The only way I know people can be a tool, is through an already existing insult.

In that case, you don't know much. It's not difficult to find examples.

For instance:

Arab-Israeli travel blogger Nas Daily denies report that he is a tool of Israeli government propaganda

( https://www.jta.org/quick-reads/arab-israeli-travel-blogger-... )

hug • yesterday at 10:20 PM

As always when discussing the usage of English words, it's pleasing to look at Webster's 1913 dictionary, which helpfully includes this definition of "tool":

> A person used as an instrument by another person; -- a word of reproach; as, men of intrigue have their tools, by whose agency they accomplish their purposes.

➕ show 1 reply