logoalt Hacker News

vrganj • today at 1:05 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Indeed, now you're getting it.

It's the only way to avoid the catastrophic power concentration issues and resource allocation issues you still haven't addressed.

It's not exactly a new concept either. All sorts of things need approval (usually ones with high resource cost and externalities, see a pattern there?), be it buildings, flight plans, oil drilling, power lines or any number of other examples.

As with some other stuff (the de minimis exception for customs comes to mind), we can of course talk about exceptions for smaller-scale personal use, but large industrial use with heavy pollution and energy use implications should be treated like any other heavy industry.

You still haven't made any case against my structural argument. You still haven't provided any evidence in favor of your viewpoint. You keep digging into hypotheticals about alternatives (at least you've stopped with the straight up strawmanning, I guess), but you've never bothered to justify the implications of the status quo you support.

Kind of funny considering how you started out by accusing others of fallacies and being morally bankrupt, mindless extremists. Maybe the shoe's on the other foot?


Replies

simianwords • today at 1:31 PM

> Kind of funny considering how you started out by accusing others of fallacies and being mindless extremists. Maybe the shoe's on the other foot?

Your utopia is me asking some one approval before I use my LLM for my own work.

I'll let others decide whether this is extreme or not.

➕ show 1 reply