logoalt Hacker News

schlich • yesterday at 5:34 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

I would love to get an expert's opinion on if Pijul has any potential to be the "non-git backend". Their patch-based data model seems to align with Scion's. And they also happen to already have a functioning forge!

I've done a decent amount of personal research on this but I'm wondering what kinds of considerations go into the storage layer for these things.


Replies

steveklabnik • yesterday at 5:54 PM

I apologize for what may come across as a bit of a cop-out answer.

As many of you know, I'm a big fan of jj. The jj project used to have a comparison to Pijul for informational purposes, but the Pijul folks took offense, and so it was removed: https://github.com/jj-vcs/jj/commit/0525dc9d860a5fff6a97d134...

As such, I generally just decline to comment on Pijul, as I want to be respectful of them. As the linked commit says, it's not super clear what exactly they do not like, and so I don't want to accidentally cross some line.

In general I wish the project well, seeing a new VCS in Rust is very cool.

➕ show 1 reply