logoalt Hacker News

IgorPartola • today at 12:15 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

There are some differences.

Temu’s UI is unusable. You are constantly presented with roulette wheels for coupons you can’t dismiss. Its dark patterns have dark patterns. AliExpress is only mildly better in that you can dismiss stuff.

Both T and A still have listings for things that will likely result in you getting something entirely different. This usually applies to more expensive and physically larger items. You might order a greenhouse and get a photo of one or a schematic of one. And I don’t mean that the description will make it clear.

Both have a pattern where they might list let’s say an MP3 player which costs $30 but the price on the listing will be $3 because one of the product variants is just the case.

Amazon has comparatively reliable shipping and it’s included with the price on a majority of products if you have a Prime membership. While Temu and AliExpress do have US-based shipping they still don’t guarantee when the thing will arrive and if you are looking at these products the price difference basically disappears.

I am not defending Amazon by any means, but purely on usability it wins hands down.


Replies

ponector • today at 4:01 PM

In my opinion, Amazon has terrible ui. It's impossible to find something unless you are looking for a particular product of well-known brand.

aembleton • today at 3:23 PM

> Both have a pattern where they might list let’s say an MP3 player which costs $30 but the price on the listing will be $3 because one of the product variants is just the case.

eBay do that too. Really annoying. Some day I'll make a browser extension to highlight it.

toyg • today at 2:21 PM

I've never had a problem with just getting a schematic, in my world that's typical of eBay (lots and lots of Apple boxes...).

The dark pattern on listing prices is real though. As it is the lower level of quality control - the same sellers will put the same product on both Amazon and Chinese stores, but the latter will get production batches that are lower quality (coil whine, etc).