Hi, most memory tools get evaluated on benchmarks like LoCoMo, LongMemEval and BEAM, plus how many tokens they use
We compared a pre-release build of Graphicle's memory with 7 other memory tools (Mem0, Hindsight and others) on three public question sets. We wrote down the test rules before scoring anything, and used one open model to read and judge the answers for every tool, so it's the same setup for all of them. Details and caveats are in docs/benchmarks.md
What we haven't done yet is the thing you're really asking: does a coding agent actually finish more tasks with these tools? We could use the same agent and model on the same tasks, with and without the tool, and compare how many tasks pass, tokens used, tool calls and time.
Curious what you're using today, and what result would convince you?
alt Hacker News
Hi, most memory tools get evaluated on benchmarks like LoCoMo, LongMemEval and BEAM, plus how many tokens they use
We compared a pre-release build of Graphicle's memory with 7 other memory tools (Mem0, Hindsight and others) on three public question sets. We wrote down the test rules before scoring anything, and used one open model to read and judge the answers for every tool, so it's the same setup for all of them. Details and caveats are in docs/benchmarks.md
What we haven't done yet is the thing you're really asking: does a coding agent actually finish more tasks with these tools? We could use the same agent and model on the same tasks, with and without the tool, and compare how many tasks pass, tokens used, tool calls and time.
Curious what you're using today, and what result would convince you?