logoalt Hacker News

sunshowers • today at 9:12 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

The level of inspiration goes well beyond "hard-won lessons". Something like Lore (slop design document aside) can claim that level of inspiration. Here the data model is a direct copy, down to the terminology.

To be uncharitable, this is marketing for Anthropic's impending IPO.


Replies

whiplash451 • today at 9:17 PM

I see correlation instead. You IPO when you grow like crazy. You build something like scion when you grow like crazy.

➕ show 2 replies
dpe82 • today at 10:19 PM

Effectively nobody considering buying into the IPO cares about Anthropic's source control system. They could be passing around floppy disks and so long as they were still shipping nobody would care.

➕ show 2 replies
solid_fuel • today at 9:47 PM

> Here the data model is a direct copy, down to the terminology.

That’s not surprising to me - they designed and built it using their LLMs, of course it’s duplicating prior work. That’s essentially the core of what LLMs do, after all.

simonw • today at 9:46 PM

Why is that bad?

Mononoke and Sapling are open source systems. Why shouldn't new software take inspiration from how they are designed?

➕ show 3 replies