logoalt Hacker News

onetrickwolf • yesterday at 7:48 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

It's a cool demo and all but I can't help but feel like it's not that impressive considering these companies control such an absurd amount of capital and this is all they can do with it. A stunt for a launch showing off features that obviously won't be in any real product.

A lot of public funds go into these companies and it just feels like they are playing around with toys instead advancing humanity. I sometimes wonder if we are not allocating resources very efficiently.


Replies

andsoitis • yesterday at 7:57 PM

> it's not that impressive co

you have to be pretty jaded to think a car that can fly through the air is not impressive.

➕ show 1 reply
kyleblarson • yesterday at 8:39 PM

They do happen to build the number one selling electric vehicle in the world.

➕ show 1 reply
manlymuppet • yesterday at 7:50 PM

Would you the same thing if it wasn't Elon Musk at the helm of this company? I'm not a big fan of him either, but I get the feeling some don't want to like this demo.

Also the public government funds being received are in the form of contracts. It's not like they can just use the money anywhere. Both Tesla and SpaceX are likely using private money (that is to say, funds not from the government) to fund this.

➕ show 1 reply
MetaWhirledPeas • yesterday at 7:58 PM

> it just feels like they are playing around with toys instead advancing humanity

You don't think electric vehicles and battery storage advance humanity?

On the contrary I would rather my big companies didn't try so hard to advance humanity. Elon has a lot of takes around creating a Utopian society which do not sit right with me. Really it's not the advancement that's the problem, it's the requisite power and resources necessary to achieve the elaborate visions. Humanity should be advanced by a collective, not by a few gifted individuals, even if that means more bureaucracy and less efficiency.

➕ show 1 reply