logoalt Hacker News

hbogert • today at 9:42 AM • 9 replies • view on HN

Ah yes the nice EU experiment where it uses the Netherlands for as their experimentation grounds. The goal of having more wild life is lofty, but it makes no sense in the netherlands . For the people who don't know, there weren't wild wolves up to 2015. There now are many and they've attacked people, horses and wiped out complete herds of sheep. The amount of sheep they are killing is increasing exponentially. (not using exponentially lightly here.) Proponents during the 2015-2020 era said that it would never come to this situation, alas.

Rhetoric questions by proponents as seen on national news website[1]:

> We hebben ook weleens last van de mens, die schieten we toch ook niet af?

> -- Aaldrik Pot

Translated:

"We also have issues with people every now and then, were not shooting them are we?"

[1]: https://nos.nl/artikel/2245512-waarom-willen-we-eigenlijk-wi...


Replies

defrost • today at 9:55 AM

The wolves seemingly made it back into the Netherlands on their own:

  In a paper published in 2016, “The first proof of the recent presence of Wolves in the Netherlands,” authors wrote:

  “In light of the expansion of wolves from the Polish border to the northwest of Germany and the sightings in Denmark, the appearance of the wolf in the Netherlands was no surprise to most experts. In March 2015, this expectation was fulfilled when, after generations without resident wolves, a single wolf wandered through the Dutch provinces of Drenthe and Groningen in broad daylight. From 7 to 10 March 2015, the Netherlands witnessed the comeback of an iconic species.”
~ https://wolf.org/wow/europe/netherlands/

Wolf numbers are now reportedly at 131 split across roughly 14 packs (April 2026): https://nltimes.nl/2026/04/11/dutch-wolf-population-growing-...

I have zero insight into why Wageningen University & Research (WUR) in the Netherlands concluded in a study that "the Netherlands are legally required to contribute between 23 and 56 wolf packs" (Lost in translation? - perhaps "can support and shouldn't cull below these numbers" ?)

~ https://www.wur.nl/en/news/ecological-and-legal-framework-wo...

➕ show 3 replies
Vinnl • today at 10:33 AM

> For the people who don't know, there weren't wild wolves up to 2015.

Well, if you go further back in time, there were. It's not like introducing a nonnative species.

➕ show 1 reply
ItsYan • today at 9:50 AM

Surely there are benefits to this. What are they? Could you provide a steel man of the opposition, please?

➕ show 2 replies
nonethewiser • today at 9:46 AM

Everyone wants wolves except the people who have to actually live with them.

➕ show 3 replies
Scarblac • today at 9:53 AM

Primarily because sheep owners refuse to install good fences.

➕ show 2 replies
throw310822 • today at 9:56 AM

It's not just the Netherlands, this is happening in Italy as well. Part of it is just the natural consequence of people having abandoned the countryside and mountains for the cities. But we certainly forgot what it means to not be the only apex predator around- we used to be able to roam around without a fear in the world like we owned the fucking place (we did). It's nice to have a wild ecosystem around but we probably forgot what it means to have around beings that are... unaligned with us.

➕ show 1 reply
saberience • today at 10:30 AM

Oh no, the poor sheep!

Why are sheep so important to protect versus wolves? They are both animals that existed in nature and can continue to exist in nature.

Why should we be morally inclined to try and "save" sheep at the expense of wolves. Sheep and goats and deer survived throughout history without the help of humans they will continue to exist, with or without the help of humans against wolves.

➕ show 2 replies
isoprophlex • today at 9:46 AM

yes for the love of god would someone please make sure the country remains a safe, boring holiday park / dairy farm. will someone think of all that poor livestock / the children!!1

➕ show 2 replies
gvfsa • today at 10:06 AM

Beep beep! We have detected your mild criticism of the EU and have applied the necessary downvotes. Have a nice day!

➕ show 1 reply