logoalt Hacker News

gruez • today at 1:29 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

1. Practically speaking, what's the intended effect, given that executions nowadays are pretty sanitized anyways? Lethal injection is basically equivalent to some guy going under anesthesia.

2. Do you actually believe in the implied principle of "if you support [x] you must watch every [x]", or are you just using it a cudgel against people you hate? Would it be fair game for anti-abortion groups to demand "if you support abortion you must watch every abortion"?


Replies

ballmerpoint • today at 1:54 PM

> Lethal injection is basically equivalent to some guy going under anesthesia.

The “safe” dose of midazolam used for anesthesia is orders of magnitude smaller than the dose commonly used in lethal injection.

> Would it be fair game for anti-abortion groups to demand "if you support abortion you must watch every abortion"?

This was actually a tactic used by anti-abortion groups back when Roe was settled law.