logoalt Hacker News

Dig1t • today at 6:45 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

The Luddites literally turned to violence when their profession was replaced by better technology. This has been happening for generations to every profession. There is joy in learning new things and developing new skills though.


Replies

thelibrarian • today at 9:41 PM

The Luddites did not resort to violence (unless you count sabotage of machinery as violence), and they were not protesting against better technology. They were protesting against the exploitation of the workers that these machines enabled. Formerly, weaving textiles was a relatively well paid and highly skilled profession, then these machines largely automated the process. This lead to the means of production being owned by the wealthy, employing badly paid and overworked people, to make themselves even richer.

runarberg • today at 7:15 PM

The “violence” was a simple act of sabotage, nobody got hurt except some peace of machinery and the wallets of the rich exploiters.

Well, that is not entirely true. The British parliament made sabotaging work machinery punishable by death. So people did in fact get hurt, the people who were hurt were the Luddites, and the people hurting them was the British state executing them.

The Luddites only wanted to keep their jobs.

krainboltgreene • today at 8:16 PM

It's so funny watching tech workers spout propaganda about the Luddites.

Brother, they're you. You just don't realize it yet.