logoalt Hacker News

tonymet • yesterday at 9:39 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Besides the practical hassle of downloading 300gb and wasting time .

It's their report, their claims, their argument. The burden to make the case and be transparent is theirs, not mine. It's dishonest to present AI summaries as facts.

There should be at least a sample of the source text so we can see how well the descriptions match the sources.

Also, where is the prompt, the model? The methods used to present the content.

It's funny how much critique of "AI slop" is on HN, and here's a case where even mild hallucination is very misleading, yet the bar is incredibly low.


Replies

striking • yesterday at 11:33 PM

The way I see it, either you are curious enough to download some of the files or you are not. I don't understand this middle ground where you spend more time complaining about the distribution method than it would take to download. It feels contrived or even in bad faith, especially given that the link above would allow you to do exactly that without starting a torrent client.

stop50 • yesterday at 9:49 PM

There is a second magnet which features all the 100k file as individual files. The packed archive is only for more efficient torrents

➕ show 1 reply
ofjcihen • yesterday at 9:51 PM

“Here’s the files so you can look for yourself”

“I refuse to and I’m still going to complain.”

➕ show 1 reply
roosterIllusi0n • yesterday at 9:52 PM

If you are bothered by not knowing, why aren't you downloading it and looking?

➕ show 1 reply