logoalt Hacker News

echelon • yesterday at 11:44 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Does anyone need Drupal anymore? You can just Claude Code all kinds of shapes of software.

I don't see how Drupal or anything like it survive. These types of softwares seem fitted to 2006, not 2026.


Replies

scottfalconer • yesterday at 11:48 PM

Using Claude to build things quickly is great - but once you hit a certain level of scale, or have a need for governed workflows & oversight, you're more or less going to want some sort of CMS. When that happens, you can either go it alone, or build on top of a lot of well discussed well thought through solutions to these sorts of problems that the Drupal community has dealt with for a couple of decades.

liveoneggs • today at 12:24 AM

Claude still has to write software in a target language, often using an established framework, especially one with a lot of examples.

PHP is, in fact, exceptionally good as a language for creating websites.

➕ show 1 reply
1shooner • today at 12:01 AM

>You can just Claude Code all kinds of shapes of software.

Drupal is used at large organizations with hundreds of sites, thousands of users, and multiple more-or-less coordinated development teams. It's actually a great target for agentic coding, because it has such a well-established internal API. It can definitely feel like an anachronism, but I think there are few projects that could replace some of it's use cases. It's the B-52 of CMSs.

➕ show 1 reply
ChrisMarshallNY • today at 1:06 AM

One of the best things about Drupal (years ago, when I used to write plugins and themes), was that you could completely customize the backend, as well as the frontend, and that was a good thing, if you have low-tech users that author content. I despise having to walk people through WordPress' backend.

But that rewriting the base system, every couple of years, was why I dropped it.

Nowadays, with LLMs, it may be time to look at it again...