logoalt Hacker News

There is no official XScreenSaver GitHub repository

36 points • by st_goliath • today at 8:51 AM • 15 comments • view on HN

Comments

bcvvvy • today at 10:48 AM

GitHub is not authoritative and never should be considered as authoritative. Anyone can publish your stuff on there as your name.

It’s a huge problem. Glad to see he’s at least put a placeholder on there.

altairprime • today at 9:48 AM

The only thing missing is to mark it as Archived so that all of the GitHub features are turned off.

amiga386 • today at 10:46 AM

Jeff Merkey is the person claiming the "xscreensaver" organisation on GitHub, despite it not being, and never has been, his project.

He has promised to drop that and move the repo to /hisname/xscreensaver, but only if JWZ flatters his ego first. Sounds like he knows he's squatting on someone else's good name, but thinks he's so clever and well versed in trademark law that he'd be deliberately antagonistic all the way to the end of a huge legal bill. Just to force him to do the right thing.

He knows what the right thing is and could do it at any time, but just look at his priors and tell me he'll do that:

https://www.dmlp.org/threats/merkey-v-does

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitra...

➕ show 1 reply
throwaway2037 • today at 10:48 AM

[flagged]

➕ show 1 reply
createful • today at 10:03 AM

So what's the point of making a GitHub if you're not going to publish source code? Is this an inside joke?

➕ show 2 replies
cookiengineer • today at 9:56 AM

Instead of providing a mirrored repository, they decided to intentionally not fixing the correctly identified problem while simultaneously still living 30 years in the past.

Setting up a git mirror that auto syncs takes less than 2mins of effort. And way less time than writing up this README that's just there to lecture people. If it's about disagreement with github, there's also better alternatives.

You can still setup the mirror and be done with it, and put the original repo links at the top in the README.

➕ show 9 replies