logoalt Hacker News

sheikhnbake • today at 2:38 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Citing classic great replacement theory rhetoric on the 'data of a disappearing people' is not compelling. Miscegenation is very human that happens in every society. Ethnicity and culture is mutable and always will be. People move and intermingle. That is human. Trying to artificially isolate a group of people with a particular set of genes is unnatural, gross, and eventually leads to genetic stagnation.

Your whataboutisms are weak. Other dominant ethnic groups can be supremacist. Backwards logic is not limited to white peoples.


Replies

Dig1t • today at 3:57 PM

To echo my sibling comment, it seems kind of like you moved from “it isn’t happening” to “it is happening but it’s a good thing”.

Don’t you think that a nation should have a conversation about how they want their own people to evolve? This is a group of people which has existed for thousands of years and this idea of open borders and pretending like race doesn’t exist is a very new idea.

Something as momentous and irreversible as ethnically replacing your own population should at least warrant a national conversation/debate about the topic.

Trying to shut down discussion by labeling it a conspiracy theory without actually engaging with the facts of the topic is just a tactic to force your worldview onto your fellow countrymen.

>Backwards logic is not limited to white peoples.

Okay well it’s good you clarified that, most normal people would not think about how Japanese people are “supremacists”. They are known for being extremely nice and welcoming to strangers. They are not “fascist” and don’t even have a military. Yet they have preserved their country and people in the way it has existed for millennia, and there are many benefits to it (high social trust etc).

Globally speaking, your worldview is in the minority and would be regarded as extreme or “backward” to many people.

➕ show 1 reply
akimbostrawman • today at 2:52 PM

"yeah, it's happening, but it's not a big deal"

➕ show 1 reply