logoalt Hacker News

MattPalmer1086 • today at 6:03 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Professor McGaugh has commented many times on the sociology of science and how the dominant paradigm tends to be hostile or indifferent to alternate views. He is also quite frank about the limitations of MOND as well, although he is definitely in the MOND camp overall.

He is hardly a crank - but he is definitely not in the mainstream camp.


Replies

canjobear • today at 7:17 PM

> Professor McGaugh has commented many times on the sociology of science and how the dominant paradigm tends to be hostile or indifferent to alternate views

This should also set off crank alarms.

➕ show 2 replies
cwmma • today at 6:13 PM

perusing his blog posts, basically if a calculation is at all within expected values, this is evidence of MOND, but for something to be evidence of dark matter it has to jump through quite a few hoops in his opinion.

He also seems to have the same problem that many MOND proponents have which is arguing for MOND in blog posts instead of in papers, though he doesn't seem to be as bad as others in this regard.

➕ show 1 reply