logoalt Hacker News

vrganj • today at 9:44 AM • 4 replies • view on HN

We are burning the only planet we have in a contest to be king of the ashes.

Who gives a fuck whether the US or China win the AI race if they both burn tons of hydrocarbon to get there? Either way, the race itself will fuck the planet up worse than either victor would.

Same about all the dumb wars of conquest, Ukraine, Iran. Who gives a fuck over those lines on a map if the map itself is on fire? All the burning of oil depots, all the explosives used are all an assault on humanity itself, not just on whatever state construct.

I have a growing suspicion that this is the Great Filter. Dumb, self-important squabbles that destroy the material basis for a species' survival in an attempt to gain control instead of cooperation.


Replies

A_D_E_P_T • today at 11:21 AM

> I have a growing suspicion that this is the Great Filter.

Ackshually... It can be our filter, but it cannot be the Great Filter.

The Great Filter has to apply universally, to every plausible society. If even a few are cooperative hiveminds, or empires ruled by an iron fist, or... whatever else you can imagine that doesn't squabble internally... then the Filter does not apply to them, which means that their absence is still weird.

The Filter has three plausible answers, IMO: (1) Some variant of the planetarium or zoo hypothesis; (2) every advanced society, universally, decides to transcend into data centers powered by rotating black holes and stable for trillions of years, or something similarly weird; potentially also New Physics, like waste heat to mass conversion; (3) the filter is in our past and abiogenesis is a lot rarer than assumed.

netsharc • today at 9:49 AM

Maybe we'll manage to launch some datacenters, then at least there'll be a backup of the database of how much each person's net worth is, floating above the dead planet...

And if we have several of them in space, they'll use blockchain, of course.

➕ show 1 reply
malloryerik • today at 10:02 AM

Never saw Game of Thrones? Which maybe should have ended with everyone dying?

➕ show 1 reply
233mhz • today at 9:53 AM

You're right but you're on the wrong corner of the internet for such take

➕ show 1 reply