logoalt Hacker News

post-it • last Wednesday at 6:59 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

"Women didn't like it and left" is certainly an interesting interpretation of the systemic exclusion of women from a field when it transitions from low-prestige manual work to high-prestige intellectual work.


Replies

mjburgess • last Wednesday at 7:51 PM

Keypunch operators were overwhelmingly women, but skilled programming was never substantially female. The obsolescence of "secretarial programming" (ie., retyping, keypunching, etc.) is the principle cause of the gender shift. Gender ratio in "formal programming" has always been ~4:1 M:F, including today.

Given now ~two decades of affirmative action for women getting into technology, and many high-status "professional industries" now dominated by women, the idea that the best explanation of this ratio is 70s/80s culture is implausible.

What we have seen, instead, is that as women are more free to choose professions the percentage of women's involvement drops.