logoalt Hacker News

jonaustin • today at 7:53 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

And veilguard was an abomination of corporate groupthink based on some perceived cultural zeitgeist. I couldn't finish it the dialogue was so painfully cringe.


Replies

torginus • today at 8:38 PM

Weird, I have a friend who's a hardcore DA fan, and he liked it, but told me it's very different.

Tbh, I think the issue is that old RPG designers understood players have very different values and goals, hell they even wrote some academic articles on it:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bartle_taxonomy_of_player_type...

The devs of today played the games of yesterday, and felt that the game catered to them, and then sought out making a game like that, but they didn't put in the effort or consideration to appeal to other kinds of players.

And turns out there's economics involved - while people playing shooters want to shoot people in general, RPG players are a diverse bunch with different needs, and if you don't scratch the itch of a certain subgroup, that's part of the audience gone.

Which results in a bomb - a game made for 20% of the playerbase will sell 20% of the copies, and will be a flop.