logoalt Hacker News

antonvs • yesterday at 11:28 AM • 0 replies • view on HN

> the concept of notation as a tool of thought, coined a quarter century later by IBM fellow Iverson

Precedence for "the concept of notation as a tool of thought" would have to go to Leibniz, 300 years earlier, in The Method of Mathematics:

> "Whence it is manifest that if we could find characters or signs appropriate for expressing all our thoughts as definitely and as exactly as arithmetic expresses numbers or geometric analysis expresses lines, we could in all subjects in so far as they are amenable to reasoning accomplish what is done in Arithmetic and Geometry.

> "For all inquiries which depend on reasoning would be performed by the transposition of characters and by a kind of calculus, which would immediately facilitate the discovery of beautiful results. For we should not have to break our heads as much as is necessary today, and yet we should be sure of accomplishing everything the given facts allow.

> "Moreover, we should be able to convince the world what we should have found or concluded, since it would be easy to verify the calculation either by doing it over or by trying tests similar to that of casting out nines in arithmetic. And if someone would doubt my results, I should say to him: "Let us calculate, Sir," and thus by taking to pen and ink, we should soon settle the question."

-- https://www.rbjones.com/rbjpub/philos/classics/leibniz/meth_...

Keep in mind that Leibniz invented the notation we still use for calculus today (as well as calculus itself), so this wasn't purely abstract for him.