logoalt Hacker News

dasyatidprime • today at 2:09 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Something seems strange about this publication. They're doing a lot of talking about machine perfection in music, but some of the articles have big chunks that read as 100% AI on Pangram, mainly “The Shame Machine” which is itself primarily about generative AI. However, I didn't observe that in the OP here, nor on the most recent post “The Climate Crisis Has A Music Problem”. Was that an early approach that's since been abandoned, or a dubious meta joke for that specific article, or what? And then the rest… clearly they have a thesis they want to keep harping on, and as someone with musical experience I'm empathetic with what seems to be the main throughline of it, but the Substack as a whole reads as being heavy propaganda for their particular certification, which is a scammy feel.


Replies

forsalebypwner • today at 2:16 PM

Literally the first sentence threw up red flags for me:

> Something happened to recorded music over the last twenty-five years that most people can hear, and feel, but almost nobody has the language for.

That is 100% Claude

➕ show 3 replies