logoalt Hacker News

bell-cot • today at 2:11 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

You aren't gonna advance your career as a prosecutor, or even win re-election, if you actually care about that "truth and justice" stuff in the case of some rando out-of stater who you already have a really cool-sounding story about the obvious guilt of.


Replies

GeoAtreides • today at 2:17 PM

having judges and prosecutor elected sure is an american experiment that i'm too european to understand

➕ show 3 replies
hvb2 • today at 2:21 PM

> or even win re-election

I mean, I would like to know what percentage of people makes an informed decision when voting for a judge for example.

A lot of them run unopposed anyway. And if they don't, I have no idea how you would figure out what candidate you like best.

Heck, in the US even the big political positions seem to be largely void of 'ideas'. It's mostly attack ads paid for by shady sources through PACs. That's where the majority of the votes are flipped/won...

morkalork • today at 2:15 PM

Democracy is cool and all but perhaps roles like judges and prosecutors should be selected on competence, not by perceived tough-on-crime popular elections

➕ show 2 replies