logoalt Hacker News

diskzero • today at 2:19 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Who does the selection? In the USA, doesn’t it always come down to voter choice one way or another? We typically elect a sheriff but a mayor appoints a police chief. The mayor is elected however. What process could be used to determine process and selection that would avoid voter input?


Replies

triceratops • today at 2:22 PM

Open application process. Select whoever had the highest law school grades. Or alternatively make all the applicants take a competitive exam. Anonymous grading.

➕ show 2 replies
pjc50 • today at 2:24 PM

Appointment by mayor or local government is fine. Make it a normal public service job. There are reasonable questions about why the US needs quite so many fine-grained local police authorities and who polices the police, though.

voakbasda • today at 2:24 PM

Make them fight to the death? Seriously, it would solve sooo many problems.