logoalt Hacker News

drnick1 • today at 4:20 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

> Assuming you even care about legality, of course.

If buying isn't owning, then piracy isn't stealing.


Replies

Buttons840 • today at 4:42 PM

The underlying principle is also more important than ever.

Laws and morals are not the same thing. What is legal may be immoral. What is illegal may be moral.

More and more I'm politically frustrated by government leaders and society just openly ignoring the law--although, I guess I did sort of argue that's sometimes okay in the last paragraph...

I guess it comes down to this. What laws do you elevate above others? What laws do you consider acceptable to ignore, and what laws do you consider morally valid?

There are some who commit moral atrocities because it's the law, we know it's sad but the law is really important and must be enforced, and then in the next breath they start an illegal war of aggression and bomb hundreds of kids. I guess the law was never really their greatest concern. Sorry if I'm being a bit too on the nose.

amelius • today at 4:26 PM

Yes and on top of that governments don't care enough about my personal information, so until this is fixed I'm not going to care about any IP or copyright laws either.

Further, big AI companies don't care about copyright laws, so I assume this is the current reality.

Laws only make sense if they are fair and applied equally.