logoalt Hacker News

iLoveOncall • yesterday at 4:32 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Grading homework has never made sense anyway. Only grade work done in class.

In-class exams are anyway a proxy for grading homeworks, because those who don't do them will get lower grades.


Replies

boothby • yesterday at 4:38 PM

I heartily disagree, grading hand-written homework serves as an early warning signal to students who don’t understand a concept* but want to. It’s also useful to keeners who like being told "you’re doing a good job, keep it up!" As well a warning to students who are so far behind that they can save time money and their GPA by dropping the class early.

And as a TA, I liked the income, and there’s a knock-on benefit that you’re learning to read with a critical eye which will help as a reviewer in the future.

* or in mine own obsolescent field, a measure of accuracy that indicates a student need think** longer before writing in the future

** I know, I know

➕ show 2 replies
dofm • yesterday at 4:36 PM

> Grading homework has never made sense anyway.

This is only true for subjects where there is only one answer to a question.

Plagiarism in other subjects tends to show itself. But AI has made plagiarism more viable in all sorts of fields.

➕ show 1 reply