One of the key teachings of Catholicism is the spiritual leadership of the Pope and his infallibility when he speaks ex cathedra.
Thiel's views go directly counter to what the Pope wrote in Magnifica Humanitas.
He cannot be properly or deeply Catholic. He can only be a hypocrite that likes the aesthetics of Catholicism, or in slightly more theological terms, a heretic.
> He cannot be properly or deeply Catholic
He’s never claimed to be - GP is confused, or just plain wrong.
I was incorrect, he is evangelical Protestant
I think lots of Catholics don't take that bit too literally though, eh? Like they might practice contraception despite what various Popes have said.