logoalt Hacker News

pixl97 • yesterday at 9:00 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

>just an invitation to consider a particular positive case.

The problem is you can't do this with made up bullshit because the creators of said bullshit can create any number of paradoxes to trap you.

Reality at least has to be self consistent.


Replies

TimTheTinker • yesterday at 9:18 PM

> you can't do this with made up bullshit

Are you saying the case for Scientology can't fail when considering its internal consistency and correspondence to reality?

I would think its positive case isn't that strong... it's more like an attack chain with an arbitrary payload (including money extraction) for minds with certain vulnerabilities than a coherent set of truth claims (let alone truth claims with at least some evidence in favor).