logoalt Hacker News

LandR • today at 11:54 AM • 4 replies • view on HN

I still get Windows 11 BSOD. That definitely hasn't gone away!


Replies

Someone1234 • today at 12:14 PM

Commonly that isn't a software issue though, that's a hardware problem being [correctly] indicated by software. With three notable exceptions:

- Windows 1.0 through ME era: Legitimately an unstable OS due to dangerous memory model/lack of memory isolation.

- Windows NT through XP: Before KPP was added, software was monkey-patching the kernel, and it was causing instability (particularly multiple trying to over-patch each other). For example during that era it wasn't UNCOMMON for antivirus to do so as a matter of course.

- Windows Vista Specific: They made significant changes to the driver model of several popular device types, and manufacturers weren't ready. So a lot of driver-related failures.

But since then, it has mostly be smooth sailing. If you see a BSOD, you can trace it down, and more often than not the source will be underlying hardware failure which is why BSOD exists and isn't a software bug or problem.

➕ show 1 reply
matja • today at 12:19 PM

And even that got worse - now there's no driver name, exception address or stop codes, so you can't even web search for anything.

➕ show 1 reply
thrownawaysz • today at 12:13 PM

Personal anecode of course but last time I've seen one was around ~2010.

epolanski • today at 12:03 PM

Since Windows 7, which was I think almost 20 years ago, I've seen a single BSOD.

I've seen more on MacOs/OSX in the same time frame.

➕ show 2 replies