logoalt Hacker News

Animats • yesterday at 7:42 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

And yet Amazon has Alexa. They have a user base for a smart chatbot. What's Alexa going to run on for hard questions?


Replies

munk-a • yesterday at 7:46 PM

They could revert to the pre-LLM craze where Alexa was actually able to answer prompts in a reasonable amount of time. Alexa is a glorified egg timer for nearly all users - it's super convenient to use a voice prompt to start/stop timers while cooking and being able to play music on voice demand is kinda alright. It genuinely doesn't need to answer hard questions.

➕ show 1 reply
layer8 • yesterday at 7:51 PM

Alexa had already been using other models like Claude depending on the question, and the French version for example uses Mistral.

dsr_ • yesterday at 7:46 PM

Basic pre-LLM speech-to-text and a passthrough to duckduckgo would beat their current product, so...

Rapzid • yesterday at 9:28 PM

Alexa+ was their LLM based release and to my knowledge it was an utter disaster and failure of product development.

Latency is the #1 UX killer on voice apps, and the latency was terrible compared to Alexa. I used it for like 15 minutes and reverted.

All anyone was talking about was how much worse it was for common tasks.