logoalt Hacker News

SmirkingRevenge • yesterday at 2:43 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

You've connected to very unrelated things unjustifiably - Immigrants and criminals

This is why advocates have always tried to reframe things from "illegal" to "undocumented"

It's actually not a crime to overstay a visa or to be here without one. It's nothing.

The act of crossing the border "illegally" is a misdemeanor (the first time) on the level of something like a speeding ticket - but its still not illegal to be here even if you crossed "illegally"


Replies

aniviacat • yesterday at 3:02 PM

Of course immigrants should follow the legal process and illegal immigrants are called that rightfully so.

If you want more people to immigrate you should make the legal pathways more accessible, not tolerate the illegal ones.

➕ show 2 replies
soon_to_be_sb • yesterday at 3:15 PM

>It's actually not a crime to overstay a visa or to be here without one. It's nothing.

If it is not a crime, then what is it?

➕ show 2 replies
marknutter • yesterday at 3:54 PM

These semantic tricks are so tiresome. If you broke a law to enter the country, I'm sorry, but you're here illegally. No amount of redefining of terms is ever going to change that.

➕ show 1 reply