logoalt Hacker News

JumpCrisscross • yesterday at 4:57 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> these actions are part of advertising their position to future voters, which is one of the key requirements in a representative democracy

Sure, this is a joint statement. Published days before the election. Meanwhile, for actual legislative priorities, draft bills are proposed.


Replies

kimixa • yesterday at 5:18 PM

Again, you're just dismissing it rather than engaging with any reasoning, and putting a rather arbitrary requirement on "real" signalling - one that has been repeatedly shown to be costly and difficult for the non-majority party to even get out of committee to a vote.

And I generally hope that actually bills have a much higher required level of analysis of details and interactions than more general direction statements. Requiring that for every statement would just put a massive burden on the minority party, as they would have to always do that level of due diligence just to be "allowed" to propose a direction.

➕ show 1 reply