alt Hacker NewsIt was all going great until I read
> The design also avoids problems like function coloring and plays well with Rust's ownership rules.
Async is not I/O. It can be used for I/O, but it's just a way of writing pure, deterministic state machines that keeps a logical flow together instead of scattered over a bunch of transitions.
Even if you choose to manually compile your async flows into explicit state machines, you still have to deal with ‘function colouring’ (a.k.a. typing): a flow that crosses several state transitions (and may have other disjoint parts of the state updated in the meantime, via other transitions) now has to be rewritten as a (series of) state transitions, and can't be called from a blocking function. If anything, rewriting all your state machines without `async` makes the function colouring ‘problem’ worse, because multi-transition flows are even more different from normal functions.
In principle, you are right. Async is not I/O. And yes, `async` functions compile to a deterministic state machine.
The problem is, the moment you use `async`, your state machine reduces down to one API: `poll`. What if I want to change some state in-between two state transitions (i.e. between two `await` points)? Now I have to wire-in a channel to supply that data at the right point or access some shared data via a Mutex.
Rust's `async` implementation is great if you know everything upfront before you kick off your state machine. The moment you need to do many things concurrently, it can become a real mess.
Firezone's sans-IO core handles many things concurrently: inbound IP, inbound UDP, WebSocket control messages, TURN allocations, timers, user commands, etc. Having essentially one big struct that I can just call `&mut self` functions on for any one of these inputs makes this very easy to understand, compose and test.
A few things like TURN request-response handshakes might be easier as an `async` function but in reality, it is not a big deal and the composability you get from it outweighs it in my opinion.