logoalt Hacker News

Veliladon • yesterday at 6:22 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

One of the most interesting things about the clip where Picard defends Data's humanity is the pronouns. Picard consistently uses he/him to refer to Data while Maddox uses it/them. Captain Louvois uses he/him during her ruling. Then, once all is said and done, Maddox finally calls Data by "he".


Replies

cortesoft • yesterday at 7:00 PM

I think about this episode a lot when people are debating AI.

Everyone who watches Star Trek roots for Data and his quest for humanity, and obviously sides with him in this 'trial'.

Yet, it seems like most people have the opposite reaction towards the current advancement of AI. Obviously, the current AI we have is not sentient in the same way Data is, and I don't think we are that close to an AI of Data's level.

However, if we are ever able to build an AI at Data's level, we have to first go through the beginning stages of AI that we are in now. We can't just skip to fully conscious AI.

So why does everyone love the AI Data, but hate the idea of working to make something like him possible?

➕ show 12 replies