From the evidence, one might dare to suggest that public education in the Soviet Union was pretty good, particularly of mathematics and the sciences. For example, the Math Circle as a social activity.
I'm also unconvinced that "Hard==Better" and that aggressive flunk-out programs are the best idea for a society.
As someone who hated undergrad math and physics approaches to vector calculus--until I found _Div, Grad, Curl and All That_--I'd argue that shitty hard textbooks are just shitty. There seems to be a cultural bias toward asceticism here, where suffering purifies the soul.
I'm also unconvinced that "Hard==Better" and that aggressive flunk-out programs are the best idea for a society.
As someone who hated undergrad math and physics approaches to vector calculus--until I found _Div, Grad, Curl and All That_--I'd argue that shitty hard textbooks are just shitty. There seems to be a cultural bias toward asceticism here, where suffering purifies the soul.