logoalt Hacker News

throw-qqqqq • today at 9:50 AM • 4 replies • view on HN

Maybe I misunderstand you, but I don’t think I agree with that.

E.g. the observable universe is finite. Its observable age is finite. The number of known elementary particle types is finite. The number of particles within the observable universe is finite (according to the current understanding). Etc.

There are many examples.

Do we disagree on this, or am I perhaps misunderstanding your position here?


Replies

worried_individ • today at 1:05 PM

besides the other points raised, even within the observable universe there are some assumed infinities as well as things that might be infinite, might not be.

e.g. time and space likely aren't quantized, you have an infinite amount of points in between any two arbitrary points in spacetime. don't mention planck scale black holes, it's a meme and even most phycisists who like to cite it haven't actually thought about it for more than 5 minutes.

tancop • today at 10:22 AM

Key word is provably. We can assume the universe is finite because we don't have evidence against it, but no one knows if it's possible to prove or reject that for good.

➕ show 1 reply
Xirdus • today at 10:41 AM

Observable universe is just the part of the universe from where light had time to hit the Earth already. It is growing pretty much at the speed of light, not because of physical changes to the space-time, but because the light from farther away finally arrived. So while it's definitely finite, I wouldn't say it disproves the claim that nothing about the universe is known to be finite.

➕ show 2 replies