logoalt Hacker News

recursivedoubts • today at 2:25 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Read from bauhaus to our house, by tom wolfe. In america we had the Arts & Crafts movement (e.g. greene & greene) as a native folk form.

It was all killed because two dynamics came together to push "the yale box": corporate america's love of cheap buildings (although the buildings are cheap to build but often nightmares to maintain and use... somebody else's problem) and the ideological purity spiraling post WW2 driven by the academic environment and the rise of abstract architectural criticism over the practical building arts.

post modernism acknowledged the failure of the yale box but, because going back to traditional building forms was unthinkable (of course), had to do ironic kitsch instead


Replies

kimi • today at 2:59 PM

> the rise of abstract architectural criticism over the practical building arts.

i.e. "any mason can build a brick house, but an architect will create an ugly box that no mason would ever have built".

➕ show 1 reply
DubiousPusher • today at 2:47 PM

Uh, I guarantee you a 1970 ranch is a far easier building to maintain than a craftsman bungalow.

Edit: I love me a craftsman bungalow but matching dry rotted custom milled trim from 90 years ago is an mfer.

➕ show 1 reply