logoalt Hacker News

suddenlybananas • yesterday at 7:17 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

>80s new wave

>it was genuinely novel

Look, I don't know the song so I can't say how novel it is, but to me, it completely misses the point if its made by a music generation model. The point of music is not to make a bunch of novel sounds. Music is a means by which a human can express themselves, the whole _point_ of art is human expression.


Replies

Liuser • yesterday at 7:31 PM

Art is subjective. It sounds like AI music did evoke an emotional response from OP, which IMO is also just as important of what we define as the purpose of art: evoking emotion and awe from consuming art. A connection is being made from the creator to the consumer. I view AI as merely another tool to that means.

Human expression with art can go both ways from producing and experiencing.

chasd00 • yesterday at 11:30 PM

Discussions about music always boil down to “stop liking what I don’t like!”.

Jtarii • yesterday at 7:31 PM

Just because its not art doesn't mean its not funny or interesting to listen to.

Bird's aren't making art when they sing, I still like listening to birds. Why can't the sounds AI make be in the same category.

➕ show 1 reply