logoalt Hacker News

acdha • today at 1:57 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

It’s staggering how much money they wasted because Musk didn’t want to listen to real experts. It was years late because stainless steel is so much harder to work with, especially when it has so many complicated geometries, and every one of those delays was a chance for him to say “maybe the people I hired for their expertise know something I don’t” rather than “I’m the boss, make it work”.

They could’ve done something like the Slate truck a decade earlier.


Replies

gangstead • today at 3:20 PM

Part of the delay was also the 48V architecture. So in addition to the obvious new things like stainless steel panels they also had to redesign mundane parts like window motors and interior lighting. The Cybercab is also using a 48V architecture so even though they've never talked about it being an R&D platform maybe they'll retcon it that way.

➕ show 1 reply
ErroneousBosh • today at 2:34 PM

> They could’ve done something like the Slate truck a decade earlier.

They could have Roadstered it.

Buy Ford Transit 350 "gliders", work out how to make them FWD, RWD, or AWD using your own transaxles and batteries. Pickup, van, or just a bare chassis-cab to go to a coachbuilder, it doesn't matter.

The Transit has been around for 61 years. Sticking electric motors in it that you already have is a no-brainer.

➕ show 1 reply
moralestapia • today at 2:38 PM

Real experts said reusable rockets were impossible ...

➕ show 3 replies
lbriner • today at 2:02 PM

> Musk didn’t want to listen to real experts

"real experts" are not always correct. A bet a lot of people told him that the original Teslas were a bad idea or SpaceX would never...wait for it...take off.

But sometimes people win when they push the boundary of what might work, push the problems to the surface and then solve them.

I don't like the guy but you can't really deny his ethusiasm and single-mindedness.

➕ show 7 replies