alt Hacker NewsReplit intrigues me. Other than Paul Graham talking it up a lot on Twitter - I've never once heard of anyone using it, seen any chatter about it in any or our internal slack forums. Every other AI company I get barraged with- no matter where I go, even antigravity/gemini carbon/argon/models/etc... - which nobody I know uses either - but at least I hear about them a lot.
I wonder what ecosystem replit exists in that seems to completely not overlap with any of the other AI technologies and companies....
Replies
I have been helping a non-profit migrate off Replit. What an awful experience using the platform has been. Their LLMs produce very bad code compared to Claude Code or Codex with the exact same prompt. Ultimately you end up having to go back and forth to get to a better solution while they nickel and dime you on tokens. It feels questionable, like it is intentional to squeeze money out of you.
Having used lovable.dev as well, I must say Lovable is a much better product.
Replit is easily one of the worst products and platforms I've use. I wouldn't even recommend it to my enemies.
I've been picking up bits of fractional CTO work over the last year or so and getting more involved with other founders... and I'm seeing plenty of people using it (and the other systems like it). They're just not generally people from a software engineering background, as you'd probably expect. So it's not a massive surprise that you're not crossing paths with them.
Generally it's entrepreneurial types who would have gone to an agency to get something built, or would have wanted to go to an agency but couldn't afford the costs involved. These platforms are far cheaper and quicker, and if we're really honest not necessarily worse quality than what they would have gotten from the vast majority of those agencies, especially the cheaper ones.
This is not a comment on whether this is a good thing or not, and I have all sorts of concerns, but it's undeniably something I'm seeing, and the nearshore/offshore agencies are certainly starting to feel the impact.
I used Replit quite a lot back in the day to share code snippets with clients.
Replit used to be a great platform for sharing code in a way which made it easy for anyone to run or modify. It was great for students, and kids learning to code. But then, in 2024, they removed all social features, and reduced the maximum number of repls for free users from practically unlimited to 3. I stopped using it after this, and shortly after, they implemented a strict ratelimit for downloading your own repls. I'm now taking a look at Replit for the first time in a while, and it looks like they completely redid their interface: Their whole web IDE appears to be gone or vastly simplified, and it seems like half of of everything I click on fails with error 429, after just a tiny bit of looking around. Their old IDE that functioned as a code editor, and gave you basic tools such as a file tree viewer, is no more. Replit turned an awesome product into a glorified LLM chat which is vastly dysfunctional for any sort of hand coding.