logoalt Hacker News

tptacek • today at 4:51 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

This seems like a super important corrective, but I don't see the agenda you're seeing. The article concludes by arguing we need to do lots more stuff, and suggests that people whose takeaway from the article is "stop doing social science interventions" should take the place of the goats in the sacrifices.


Replies

titanomachy • today at 6:44 PM

If true, it would somewhat undermine another point of the article, which is that since almost all of our interventions are ineffective we need to invest more in understanding which ones actually work.

I'm sure that many other examples could be found to replace this one, but if a lot of the "ineffective interventions" turned out to be effective under closer scrutiny then it would be a blow to the thesis for sure.