logoalt Hacker News

tjwebbnorfolk • today at 5:50 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

The goal of a scientific experiment can't be to "help" people. What you're describing is a political experiment. The goal of science can only be to learn whether it helps people, who it helps, who it hurts, etc.

> whenever you see some kind of large scale statistic that you think is not what it should be, the last thing you should do is concoct a large scale intervention to try to change it

aint that the truth.


Replies

_heimdall • today at 5:54 PM

Duplicating a top level comment I just posted, but this all assumes that people will generally respond the same way over time. I'd be surprised if culture, societal norms, life experiences, etc didn't make a meaningful difference and those absolutely change over time.

➕ show 1 reply