logoalt Hacker News

altruios • yesterday at 10:13 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

>it has nothing without an input.

Show me a human with no input. Show me anything alive without a constant stream of 'input'. Without input, human or robot, there is no output.


Replies

nullsanity • today at 12:49 AM

[dead]

annoyingnoob • yesterday at 10:36 PM

Ok sure, we have sensory inputs. What can your AI sense?

https://archive.ph/p8IBc

Try throwing your young AI in with a pack of dogs. Would it survive? It would do nothing. Once again, you can try to make your clanker look human but its not. A pack of dogs can't teach your AI to be like a dog, your AI cant observe dogs on its own and start behaving like them. The concept of a soul in AI is hogwash.

Can you examine my brain and find the soul? Can you find my personality in there? Why not?