logoalt Hacker News

ShinyLeftPad • today at 4:29 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

We pretty much never only judged the output. An oil painting is valued because it's an oil painting among other things. If people know you have worked on something for a long time, it's valued more than something you just came up with this afternoon. A chair crafted by a woodworker, even if it's worse in some ways, is valued over an IKEA chair produced in a fraction of the time.

Generative models are like outsourcing to cheap mass production factory, not an advanced woodworking tool in your basement.


Replies

tomcatfish • today at 4:42 PM

Both of those things are visible in the output. An Ikea chair isn't denigrated because we're such snobs, but because it's made of inferior materials. If Ikea started selling solid hardwood bookshelves tomorrow at the same price as their other stuff, I'd be driving right over there!

➕ show 3 replies
Toynbeeidea • today at 5:37 PM

Hmm, I don't know that time invested inherently equates to quality. I would place FAR more value on a comfortable functional mass-assembled chair than some wobbly piece of crap some guy spent two weeks cobbling together in his garage.