logoalt Hacker News

ablob • today at 7:23 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

So deleting the files when not prompted to is correct behavior?

Files not recovered -> human in the wrong

Files recovered due to independent backup -> no problem

Is there any scenario in which you'd accept Claude's behavior as faulty here?


Replies

brg • today at 7:26 PM

I believe every reader understands that Claude’s behavior is faulty here, what the disagreement is whether or not it is a tragedy. As the result of the error is a minor inconvenience, there is no tragedy.