logoalt Hacker News

trinsic2 • today at 3:16 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

Yep that solves everything. Pack your bags guys. War's over on ALPR's [sarcasm]

Making things illegal does not stop abuse. The cameras should not even be in our communities. There was 0 discussion nor any vote. These things got installed without consent and you want to argue that just placing guardrails that don't even get enforced is going to fix this?


Replies

aurmc • today at 3:50 AM

Ultimately this is the actual right answer. Strong regulation is great, but it won't actually curb abuse enough.

Nobody ever wanted this except people with unreasonable pearl-clutching arguments about safety. We've had these devices for years now, and we haven't seen studies showing massive safety improvements in communities that are blanketed in these cameras. We've reached a point where cars are drenched in tracking devices -- I left two separate AirTags in my car, and the car itself also came with online tracking from the manufacturer -- and car theft still happens. Desperate people will commit car thefts whether there are cameras tracking them or not.

These are -- and always have been -- the "cop's ex-girlfriend tracking machine".

"But now the ALPR has to check the plate against a list of plates that it's been told to scan for and then delete non-hits!" That's great, but if a cop can add plates to the list, then they'll just add the plate for the woman they're stalking to the list and then wait 24 hours to see where she goes. The "non-hit rule" is like telling cops to wear body cams in the hope that they'll stop committing police brutality. Feels nice, but they just keep doing it anyway. Just tear these things down.

➕ show 1 reply
__MatrixMan__ • today at 3:55 AM

They're basically litter.

➕ show 1 reply