logoalt Hacker News

pseudohadamard • yesterday at 7:15 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

This is a really impressive piece of work, a scope isn't just a generic SBC with an ADC attached, it's a huge amount of fully custom analog and digital circuitry that you need to work with, combined with extensive signal processing software requirements, UI code, and so on. Julian (with some AI help) has essentially replicated what an entire dev team at Rigol did over quite a long period of time, it's actually worth getting a Rigol over other similar brands just for this.

Ob-direct link to the repo: https://github.com/deckerjulian/oos


Replies

Aurornis • today at 4:18 PM

> scope isn't just a generic SBC with an ADC attached, it's a huge amount of fully custom analog and digital circuitry that you need to work with,

Oscilloscopes are an interesting target for projects like this because a lot of the difficult low level work is cleanly separated from the UI. It’s in the FPGA bitstream or signal processing code that might be completely separate from the UI.

The UI app isn’t exactly trivial because handling large volumes of data at high speed on limited hardware never is, but it doesn’t require reimplementing the entire firmware stack of the scope.

That’s what makes me optimistic about these projects. There is a lot of room to fix the UI and make it expandable by the community.

Doohickey-d • today at 12:59 PM

At least from the eevblog post, it seems like the only re-implemented part is the "host" side, so Linux. A scope also has an FPGA, which is where the signal processing, sample memory, and acquisition happens. This one is much harder to reverse engineer, because it's effectively impossible to decompile the bitstream back to code (verilog), it's not possible to debug it in any meaningful way, so you're really starting from scratch in the dark. And it's extra hard, because you need to know what's connected to which pin on the FPGA, which is impossible to do without desoldering it or destroying the board.

➕ show 2 replies
fock • today at 12:52 PM

"a lot of AI help" I assume...

➕ show 2 replies