alt Hacker NewsSeriously cannot believe the PWM frequency is 240Hz. I was shocked out of my mind when I first saw that. It needs to be on the order of kHz to avoid eyestrain for a very significant proportion of the population. Did Apple just forget about accessibility, or did they underestimate it?
Replies
PWM frequency is not selected in a vacuum. The maximum is set by your transition time which is set by a bunch of other engineering decisions. It's possible that something about tandem OLEDs make them more difficult to drive faster edges on.
Slight aside. I was thinking of buying a Google Pixel 11 but I learned that they have the same problem. I will go into a store and see if the Pro version (which can do 480 Hz) is OK.
Even if I'm not sensitive I am wary of this, what if it causes subtle eye strain that has long-term consequences?
OLEDs commonly flicker at some small multiple of the refresh rate because they often use something somewhat similar to DLP bit-plane modulation to avoid non-linearity at low brightness. You can't do that at xy kHz because that would require xy kHz scanout to the panel, which is physically ... not very plausible. You can gate drive current, but then you're back to how a 2010 LED backlight operates.
This: https://www.notebookcheck.net/fileadmin/Notebooks/Apple/MacB... is perceptually very different from a low frequency low duty cycle PWM you'd get out of a cheap LCD backlight.
All OLED iPhones flicker below some brightness threshold, for example.
I Think Apple gets progressively worse and worse and I mean in a general way. There are some anomalies there and there but overall the direction is a slow decline in details and quality.
I love me some high end electronics that doesn’t feel cheap but soon it will be not worth it.
Ok but who can actually see 240hz?
Like CRTs scan slower than that, and almost no-one could say they could see the pixels being drawn.
Sure you could hear those fuckers, but not see them, unless you had a source of vibration nearby.
Howe much of this is measurable, and how much of it is similar to the Himalayan salt lamp stuff?
Forget, no. Liquid glass? They've abandoned accessibility.
OLED plus dark mode is a way to juice advertised battery life.
> Did Apple just forget about accessibility
To this day on macOS, the font size accessibility setting only works on first-party apps!
Even when using Apple's own UI frameworks, and using semantic font sizes that do actually scale up and down on iOS / iPadOS
It astonishes me!